I spent my first five years living in a quiet neighborhood not far from the hospital. In 1967, all hell broke loose in Detroit. My parents hoped that life eventually would return to normal, but the riots changed the city forever, and in 1968 we moved to nearby Southfield. Our new house in suburbia was only seven miles away from our old one in Detroit, but in reality we had moved to a whole new world.
Even as a kid I was interested in current events, so I knew that the 1970’s were not kind to Detroit, nor to the automobile industry, which was the backbone of the city’s economy. I knew that inflation, oil prices, rampant crime, racial tensions and Vietnam all were taking their toll on my hometown. Still, I have fond memories of growing up in the Detroit area. Although we lived in the suburbs, we had our reasons to venture back into the city: baseball games at Tiger Stadium, Downtown Detroit Days at Hudson’s and Crowley’s department stores (new clothes for the school year), giant hamburgers at Carl’s Chop House on Grand River, feeding the ducks on Belle Isle or in Palmer Park, Jewish High Holiday services at Temple Beth El on Gladstone, and driving down Woodward Avenue to see the magnificent Christmas lights.
After leaving the area in 1977, I spent four years in dour Milwaukee, my college years in vibrant Minneapolis, and twenty wonderful years in Washington, D.C. I am now very happy to call northern California home. I periodically return to Detroit for various family events and to visit my grandmother. When I visit with my parents and sisters -- all of whom are now in California -- we always take a trip down memory lane. We get in the car and drive through our old neighborhoods in Detroit and Southfield, and make the trek down Woodward Avenue all the way to its foot at the intersection with Jefferson Avenue on the banks of the Detroit River. For my parents especially, these trips are both nostalgic and depressing, and remind us that Detroit, and what Detroit use to be, is a faint memory.
Detroit once was a shining example of a vibrant U.S. economy. During World War II this “arsenal of democracy” helped to arm an emerging superpower and its allies in the fight against tyrannical fascism. In the post-war era, Detroit put America and much of the world on wheels. In doing so it created seemingly boundless prosperity for all, but the good times did not last long. Today, Detroit is the poster child for the decline in manufacturing, the indifference of political and business leaders, and the dangers of rampant crime and poor urban planning.
Detroit's downward spiral has been long and painful. The city’s population peaked at nearly 2 million in the early 1950s at the same time that domestic auto production hit an all-time high. By 1960, the Detroit automakers were facing stiff competition from their German and Japanese counterparts. Moreover, technology was taking its toll as automation began replacing assembly line workers. By 1961, Chrysler, once the city's biggest employer, had dropped 80,000 workers from its payroll. At the height of the 1958 recession, Detroit’s unemployment rate hit 20%, and although the employment picture brightened in the early 1960s, as early as 1961, the United States Department of Labor listed Detroit as “an area of substantial and persistent unemployment.''
The 1967 riots were a critical juncture in Detroit’s history and the point of no return. They began on my 4th birthday -- Saturday, July 22, 1967. That night police raided an unlicensed, after-hours bar on the city's near west side. The Detroit police expected to find only two dozen people inside the bar, but instead were confronted by nearly 100 people celebrating the return of two local Vietnam War veterans. The police decided to arrest everyone in the attendance. A crowd soon gathered around the establishment to protest as patrons were led away. As dawn broke on July 23rd, this one raid had evolved into one of the deadliest and most destructive riots in American history.
Although most of the riot activity occurred in localized areas around Woodward Avenue (the city’s main north-south thoroughfare), on East Grand Boulevard and on Michigan Avenue near Tiger Stadium, the whole city was affected. During the five days of rioting a citywide curfew was enacted, sales of alcohol and firearms were prohibited, and downtown businesses shut down as civil unrest engulfed sections of the city.
Governor George Romney ordered the Michigan National Guard into Detroit, and President Lyndon B. Johnson sent in Army troops. The result was 443 dead, 467 injured, over 7,200 arrests, and more than 2,000 buildings destroyed by fire and looting.
The city itself, however, was the biggest casualty. The damage was long-term and permanent. The riots put the city on the fast track to social and economic devastation. And unlike other rust belt cities, such as Pittsburgh and Cleveland, which have seen at least a partial renaissance, Detroit never recovered and I fear it never will. Jobs, services, tax dollars, investment dollars, tourism dollars and development dollars fled the city along with thousands and thousands of citizens.
The exodus from Detroit started in the early 1960s, but became frantic after the riots, and hit its peak in 1968, when my family gave up on Detroit and moved to Southfield. And it wasn’t just a white exodus, Detroit’s large black middle class also left the city in large numbers. The city is now home to only 713,000 residents, and nearly half of them live below the national poverty rate. Today, the city’s unemployment rate tops 30%, although local leaders believe that the actual rate is closer to 50% because many of Detroit’s residents stopped looking for jobs a long time ago.
One reason for the high unemployment is that businesses are not willing to take a chance on a city that is noted for political corruption and cronyism, high crime and deteriorating infrastructure. I noted at the beginning that there is one Home Depot within Detroit’s city limits; however, don’t go looking for a large grocery store. National grocery store chains have given up on the city – there is not one Safeway, Kroger, A&P or Whole Foods in Detroit. City residents must either shop in the suburbs or at independent stores that constantly struggle to remain in business.
I was in Detroit with my mother last weekend to visit my grandmother, who is celebrating her 101st birthday this month. Grandma was born in downstate Illinois, and like so many of her generation, migrated with her parents and six brothers to Detroit in the 1920’s because it offered greater economic opportunity. In her lifetime she has seen Detroit’s boom and its bust.
To celebrate her birthday, my mother and I took grandma shopping and out for a nice lunch at a suburban shopping mall. Afterward, I got in the car by myself and took my own trip down memory lane. I drove up Telegraph Road to Pontiac, and then swung south onto Woodward Avenue for the 31-mile trip to downtown Detroit. And although I passed through some beautiful suburban areas, with sparkling lakes and beautiful houses, this particular trip down memory lane was more of a study in urban blight. Once I passed the Detroit Zoo at Woodward and 10 Mile Road – still two miles outside the city limits -- the landscape turned dreary and desolate. As I ventured closer to downtown I felt like I was driving through a war zone and witnessing the destructive aftermath of a fierce battle. In reality, I was passing through a dead city, which has suffered for decades from political mismanagement and societal neglect. When I finally returned to my hotel back in pristine West Bloomfield, I was more than ready to pack my bags and fly home to California.
To those of us who are part of the Detroit diaspora, Thomas Wolfe is right, “you can’t go home again.” And sadly, I don’t think many of us would want to.